He purchased a xbox live code ( tangible item ) on 10/28/12.
Seller sent him a email verification code immediately to confirm his email address , but he NEVER replied back.

3 weeks later 11/17/12 he finally email seller back with the security code, PLUS open a PP " non-receipt dispute ".

He wrote:
" I have not received the Xbox 12 month gold membership valid code that I had bought from you. Please send or I will have the money refunded. "

and

" Enter response ASAP or I will escalate with PayPal ".

What the hell?
It was him that took 3 weeks to reply, wasn't it?

It looks like he did not even know the problem is on his side!

If a buyer purchase something off internet but never read/reply any emails, nobody can help!