Bought a tool set and then wanted to return it. Upon the return we found that he put his broken set in the box and sent it back to us. Ebay, of course is of no help whatsoever, so we got screwed. Hopefully you wont be by reading this first!
Escalate the claim, show the pictures, make sure the serial numbers of everything you have are documented and posted in the listing. If he pulls the bullshit again then submit it to paypal. We've been getting some scumbags from MD that have pulled the con job. EBay knows they screw over sellers and keep screwing them over time and time again.